10 shiplap mistakes that are making your farmhouse walls look cheap

Shiplap walls have become a hallmark of farmhouse style, known for their rustic charm and clean lines. However, achieving that perfect look requires attention to detail and a careful approach to installation. When done right, shiplap can elevate a space, giving it a warm, inviting feel. But if missteps are made, those beautiful boards can end up looking cheap and detract from the overall aesthetic.

In this article, we’ll explore common shiplap mistakes that can undermine your design efforts. From material choices to installation blunders, each misstep offers a lesson in what to avoid. Whether you’re a seasoned DIYer or a first-time renovator, these insights will help you achieve a stunning farmhouse finish.

When selecting shiplap for high-traffic areas like hallways or living rooms, material choice is crucial. Opting for a thin, low-quality wood or MDF can result in boards that easily dent or warp over time. Instead, choose a durable hardwood or exterior-grade plywood, typically at least 1/2 inch thick, which will hold up better under pressure.

Consider the environment as well: if your shiplap is likely to be exposed to moisture, such as in a bathroom or kitchen, look for moisture-resistant options. Cedar or treated pine can be good choices here, as they resist warping and moisture damage.

The width of your shiplap boards can drastically affect the visual balance of a room. Oversized planks can overwhelm a small space, while narrow boards might feel too busy in a large room. Standard shiplap widths range from 5 to 7 inches, but adjusting your choice based on room size is key.

In smaller rooms, narrower boards can help maintain proportion without overcrowding the walls. Conversely, wider boards can create a sense of continuity and expansiveness in larger spaces. Keep the scale of furniture and other architectural elements in mind as well to ensure a cohesive look.

Shiplap is designed to have a distinct shadow line between each board, thanks to its rabbeted edges. Installing boards backwards, with the groove facing outwards, can eliminate this effect, resulting in a flat and uninspired look.

Always orient the boards correctly, with the tongue facing upward and the groove downward, to ensure the shadow lines are visible. This small detail is vital for creating the depth and texture that epitomizes classic shiplap walls.

Proper spacing between shiplap boards is essential to accommodate natural expansion and contraction of the wood. Failing to leave adequate gaps can lead to warping or buckling as humidity levels change.

Use a nickel or a dedicated spacer tool to maintain a consistent gap of approximately 1/8 inch between each board. This spacing not only prevents damage but also enhances the visual impact of the shiplap by emphasizing the shadow lines.

Before hanging shiplap, ensure the wall surface is smooth and clean. Installing over uneven or flawed surfaces can lead to visible imperfections that detract from the final look. Sand down any bumps and fill in holes to create an even foundation.

Additionally, consider painting or priming the wall in a similar color to your shiplap beforehand. This step ensures that any gaps between boards blend seamlessly into the background rather than drawing attention to themselves.

The finish of your shiplap plays a significant role in its overall appearance. Glossy paint can emphasize every imperfection, from uneven surfaces to nail holes. Instead, opt for a matte or eggshell finish, which will create a more refined and authentic look.

High-quality paint is also crucial. A durable, washable paint will ensure your shiplap maintains its beauty over time, even in high-use areas. Consider using a primer-sealer to prepare the surface and enhance the paint's longevity.

While white shiplap is a classic choice, an overly bright white can create a stark, sterile environment rather than the warm, inviting farmhouse feel you’re aiming for. Opt for softer, warmer whites with subtle undertones to add depth and character.

Consider incorporating other colors or natural wood finishes into your design to break up the monotony and add interest. This approach creates a layered, authentic look that evokes the charm of a traditional farmhouse.

Attention to detail is critical when installing shiplap. Sloppy seams, visible nail holes, and poorly finished corners can quickly cheapen the appearance of your walls. Use a nail gun to secure boards and fill in any holes with wood filler for a seamless finish.

Be mindful of your cuts, particularly in corners and around trim. Mitered edges create clean, professional-looking joints. Sand down any rough spots and apply touch-up paint as needed to achieve a polished, finished look.

The direction in which you run your shiplap can significantly affect the perception of space in a room. Horizontal shiplap can make walls look wider, which is ideal for narrow rooms. Vertical installation, on the other hand, can draw the eye upward, making a room feel taller.

Consider the natural light in the room as well. Horizontal lines can enhance the flow of light, while vertical lines might create a more dramatic effect in spaces with high ceilings. Choose the direction that complements the room’s proportions and natural lighting to enhance its overall ambiance.

While shiplap can add charm to many spaces, overusing it can make a home feel monotonous and uninspired. Reserve shiplap for areas where it can serve as a focal point, such as accent walls or specific rooms like the living room or kitchen.

Consider the existing style of each room before deciding to add shiplap. In more contemporary or minimalist spaces, a different wall treatment may be more appropriate. Balance is key—use shiplap strategically to highlight your home’s best features without overwhelming its overall design.